For an iPhone App it’s no secret that a great way to help your app show up on App Store searches is to have a ton of current and excellent reviews/ratings. (Also helps to have a lot of downloads and keywords in your meta data that are popular and consistent with your app.) Besides the holy grail of being featured by Apple, we’re convinced the next best way to get your app noticed is through App Store search.
Prospective users also like to see a bunch of 4 to 5 Star ratings and reviews. It gives us confidence that we’re not wasting our time or money. Amazon and TripAdvisor have been the best at leveraging reviews to “close a sale.”
So, if reviews are so important what’s the best way to get them?
The theory goes that if users love your product (or are really pissed off) they’ll go to the marketplace or site and write a review. But that takes a lot of steps. I wouldn’t be surprised if 95% of people that thought of leaving a review (either positive or negative) never get around to it. We all have too many to-dos. Stuff gets in the way.
(Recently there were was some press about companies giving away their product in exchange for reviews. I’m all for incentives but that just feels wrong. You’re basically paying for a review and I sure hope that backfires for companies that try that.)
So what to do? Amazon will send you an email after a few days of receiving the product asking for a review. Like all email, most of it doesn’t get seen or acted upon. But Amazon just makes it up on volume. What’s an aspiring boot-strapped start-up to do?
One advantage of iPhone Apps is that you have the user’s attention while they’re using your app. You could time your ask for when the user has experienced some delight. For us, that’s sharing video. So for free users we’ll ask for a review after your 2nd, 5th and 8th share. After your 12th share and every 3rd share after that we’ll give the user the “No Thanks” option so they’re not asked again.
For paying users we’ll ask after your 2nd, 6th and every 3rd share after that. Starting with your 6th share we’ll give you the “No Thanks” option.
Here’s how it looks:

If you tap “Rate Now” you’ll be taken to the App Store review page and we’ll stop asking for a review whether you leave a review or not. (We don’t know either way.) On the 3-button version if you tap “No Thanks” we won’t ask again. When we release a major update (likely every 9 months or so) we’ll reset the count.
We’re trying to balance:
- making it super easy for folks to review us in the moment
- getting reviews so we show up on searches
- not annoying users
Time will tell if we got this right. What do you think?